When people think of San Diego, they often imagine stunning beaches, perfect weather, and vibrant cultural and artistic scenes. But for those drawn to the paranormal, San Diego offers a compelling invitation—with its deep, shadowy history, haunted locations, mysterious spiritual encounters, and unexplained phenomena.
The Whaley House might seem like just another old brick building, but it has earned the title of the “most haunted house in America”—once from Time Magazine and again from the Travel Channel’s Ghost Adventures. So what is it about this modest two-story home in historic Old Town San Diego that draws so much supernatural attention? With as many ghost stories as historical events tied to it, the house’s reputation is well deserved. As soon as I heard the Travel Channel name it the “most haunted place in America,” I knew I had to see it for myself.
From the moment you step onto the property, the haunted theme is front and center. The gift shop alone stocks at least 15 different books all about the house’s ghostly reputation. You can even pick up a “Got Ghosts?” mug or T-shirt if you’re feeling into it. After paying my $10 admission, I left the gift shop and made my way into the main house.
The house carries a long and often tragic history. Throughout the years, it has served many roles: a granary, San Diego’s first commercial theater, and the county courthouse. It was also home to the Whaley family from 1857 to 1885, and again from 1909 to 1953. Built by family patriarch Thomas Whaley using bricks from his own brickyard, the Whaley House was San Diego’s first two-story brick building.
To uncover the origins of the Whaley House hauntings, you must look back even before the house existed. The land where the Whaley House now stands once served as a makeshift gallows. In 1852, James “Yankee Jim” Robinson was convicted of attempted larceny and was hanged from the back of a wagon right on that very spot.
According to newspaper accounts of the time, the hangman set the noose improperly, allowing Jim’s feet to graze the ground, prolonging the hanging process. “Yankee Jim” kept his feet on the wagon as long as he could, and when he was finally pulled off, he swung back and forth like a pendulum until he strangled to death.”
Thomas Whaley witnessed the execution but wasn’t deterred from purchasing the land to build his family home in 1857. Shortly after moving in, the family began hearing heavy footsteps echoing through the house—footsteps that Thomas described as sounding like the “boots of a large man.” Over time, the family came to believe these mysterious sounds were the work of the ghost of “Yankee Jim.”
(In 1869 the city leased this room as a courthouse. As the population grew in San Diego’s “New Town” the city fathers wanted to also move the public records out of Old Town. A heavy iron chain in the room has been seen to swing on its own, and many people report feeling uneasy there. Heavy footsteps have long been heard upstairs, above this room.)
“Yankee Jim” wasn’t the last death that the Whaley House would see. Many Members of the Whaley family are said to have never truly left the home that bears their name. Thomas and Anna Whaley are both believed to haunt the house—Thomas is often seen standing at the top of the staircase, while Anna usually appears in the parlor, both dressed in Victorian-era clothing. Their son, Thomas Jr., who tragically died of Scarlet Fever at just 18 months old in 1858, is also thought to linger in the house. His sudden, early death may have trapped his spirit, as many visitors report hearing the sounds of a child within the Whaley House.
Another restless spirit is Violet, one of the Whaley children who suffered greatly. After being shamed, abandoned, and deceived by her husband, Violet fell into a deep depression. At just 22 years old, she returned to her family home and tragically ended her life by shooting herself in the chest. Many who visit the spot where she died report overwhelming feelings of sadness.
Even the family pets—Whaley’s dog and cat—are said to haunt the house, occasionally seen playfully chasing each other inside and throughout the gardens.
In the mid-1800s, a young girl running down the hill outside accidentally caught her throat on a clothesline, causing fatal injury. She was brought into the kitchen, where she later passed away on the kitchen table. Since that time, witnesses have reported seeing a blonde girl in the kitchen and running through the yard. Pots and pans hanging on the kitchen wall have also been seen mysteriously moving on their own.
In 1871, while Thomas was away on a business trip, a group of armed men stormed the Whaley home, holding Anna Whaley at gunpoint as they seized the courthouse records stored there. Many believe this traumatic event marked a significant turning point for both the family and the house.
No one has lived in the Whaley House since 1953, and over the years, various restoration crews have come and gone, working to preserve the building. The historic home officially opened as a museum on May 25, 1960. Visiting the Whaley House today feels like drawing back a curtain to step straight into the 1850s—the era of stagecoaches and crinolines—in what was once the only “grand mansion” in a dusty frontier town.
(The archway between the parlor and music room is located where Yankee Jim Robinson was hung in 1852, before the house was built. People report feeling a constriction in the throat when standing there.)
Over the years, many visitors to the Whaley House have reported experiencing ghostly phenomena within its walls. Common accounts include hearing unexplained sounds such as loud bangs, whispering, laughter, moaning, and even screams and crying. The list of witnesses includes celebrities as well—comedian Tom Green once called out to the spirits in one room and was reportedly answered by a child’s voice captured on tape. Meanwhile, in 1964, Regis Philbin visited the house and claimed to see the ghostly presence of Anna Whaley—a “filmy white” apparition that appeared right in front of her portrait.
Unfortunately, I wasn’t lucky enough to encounter any ghosts during my visit. But when it comes to spooky, the creepiest thing I came across were the dolls scattered throughout the rooms. Honestly, I didn’t need to see a ghost—those dolls were unsettling enough on their own!
With a long history of tragedy and misfortune, it’s hardly surprising the Whaley House has earned the title of “the most haunted house in the U.S.”
If you’d like to view more haunted history on the house check out season 9 episode 12 of Ghost Adventures on the Travel Channel. For visitors the house is located at 2476 San Diego Ave in San Diego. Price of adult admission is $10. This is a self-guided tour, but plenty of docents are readily available to answer any questions you may have.
Wander Woman 